Need help deciding if shutters work on your home? Here are some before and after photos of reader-submitted homes along with a few design guides to help you decide on shutters or not.
Wow, I received a lot of photos when I made my request last week! Thank you so much for responding. My readers are the best!
Once again, shutters look the best on windows where it looks like they can close over them.
However, there are exceptions to this rule. And shutters need to be considered on a case-by-case basis, so hopefully, my commentary on the following homes will help you make a confident decision if your house didn’t make it in this roundup.
Shutters or not?
First, let’s consider if my house is the exception to the rule of ‘shutters should look like they can close over the windows’.
This is what it looked like after we removed all the old shrubs right after we took possession.
If I was just staring at my naked house with zero landscaping (above) I might have thought the windows on the right needed shutters. The wall looks a bit empty, especially when compared to the much larger windows on the left side.
This is also the time when bad stone or brick gets installed along the waterline of the house as well. When we don’t realize how much of our yard can be transformed by landscaping. That’s when we think the house needs an added stone detail.
Landscaping is decorating for the exterior after all. I have two video modules about this topic in my Exterior Masterclass.
Just like, if you are looking at your bare kitchen without any styling, you might decide it needs that snappy accent tile after all.
Read more: Dos and Don’ts for Installing Accent Tile
Here’s my house with landscaping:
Does my house still need shutters? Well let’s find out, shall we? Here’s a look at some shutters photoshopped on my windows.
There are a few reasons I don’t think this is the best look for my house. Not only do they look wrong because they aren’t visually wide enough to actually close and cover the windows (which is a key design feature you need to consider – even if you never intend to close them).
But also, I think this added detail looks like too much. Here’s the other thing – they can’t be white to match the trim because then you end up with a cottage look. So I photoshopped them in taupe to coordinate with the roof.
And here it is with them removed. Better. I think we can safely conclude that the landscaping won in this case.
Let’s look at some reader homes to see if they work with shutters or not:
Shutters or not? Exterior #1:
Does this house need shutters or should we add some additional landscaping instead?
What do you think? Better or not?
Personally, I like this home better without shutters. It’s just too many shutters (and in the end they should have been slightly skinner) However, we do need additional landscaping – perhaps a tree or two out front. And that’s what I would focus on here.
Shutters or not? Exterior #2
“Maria, I know for sure that I don’t want to replace the shutters on the 3 living room windows (to your comment that two shutters won’t cover three windows) but I don’t know if I should replace the shutters on the rest of the windows. I’m thinking about painting the house blue and the shutters white but still undecided about color.”
You know, I love the idea of a blue and white house. This definitely has a cottage feel to it! However, I agree it does not need shutters as you’ve said.
Many people talked about the back of their house and let me reassure you there. Unless you want it to be prettier FOR YOU, it’s not part of the curb appeal and doesn’t need shutters.
Shutters or not? Exterior #3
“I’m so glad you asked for pics because I have been wondering this. You can’t tell, but the existing shutters are wood and several of them are very warped and need to be replaced. The house faces west, so I’m afraid any shutters we’d replace them with will fade and look terrible from all the sun exposure here in the hot Tennessee sun.
I’d love to go without, but don’t know if will be too much orange brick and not enough architectural interest. I do have climbing roses starting to grow up the brick on the right wing. And the trees next to the porch are leafed out now, burgundy-colored Japanese maples.
I’d love any thoughts you have! If you do suggest shutter, is the current good?”
So, in this case, I didn’t need to photoshop the house without shutters. It looks perfect with them and in addition the shutters on the second floor definitely help visual balance the wider windows below on the first floor.
Shutters or not? Exterior #4
“Maria, I think my house would look crazy silly w/o them?! Now you have me questioning it :)”
I agree, this house needs shutters and it looks good the way it is. However, perhaps what bothers you about your house are the two random arched windows, especially the one positioned in the centre of the facade. Unfortunately, an architect got creative here.
Shutters or not? Exterior #5
“With shutters” is the before photo showing the house as originally built.
Two years ago when I was educated as to how shutters are supposed to look, we removed them and “no shutters” is a current photo. Now I’m wondering if “no shutters” looks OK or if I should add shutters to the top floor middle window and the two windows on the bottom floor left and maybe bottom floor right window as those could look as if they can cover the windows. Would love your opinion, Maria, it has served us so well so far!”
I like this house without shutters. They bother me in the image with shutters on ALL the windows. And I don’t think adding them just on the skinny windows does enough to the curb appeal.
Also, I believe this house needs to be painted a colour instead of white. Even adding a tree or two would be add some visual interest to the exterior and take the attention away from the naked windows. However, in this case, I prefer them naked.
PS. this reader sent a photo of a better picture that did include trees and here it is:
Shutters or not? Exterior #6
This email simply stated, “No shutters and I like it!.”
And, I would agree. It would look really busy otherwise with each of the shutters butting up to the next one.
At first I thought maybe the dark trim around the front door would look better painted white but when I photoshopped out the screen door and added a colour, I changed my mind.
Shutters or not? Exterior #7
“Thank you for looking at this photo of my house. I think I made a classic mistake with the shutters when the house was built 22 years ago but I’m worried it will be like eyes without eyelashes if I remove them. There is a third window with shutters, obscured by the Japanese Pine. The door and the shutters are all painted in BM Essex Green. I have to say I’ve learned so much from your blog and e-books, and I love my new undertones wheel!”
Well what do you think? Shutters or no? Let’s see what this house looks like without shutters:
I have to say I prefer the house without shutters. Maybe because so much of the black roofline is visible and when combined with the black shutters on the too-wide windows, it doesn’t work. I’m not a fan of so much black, especially when combined with orange brick on the house (it starts looking halloween after all).
I do like that they matched the orange colour of the brick for the gable with stucco, you don’t even notice it until you start looking.
Also the Japanese pine is getting large out front, but see how pretty it is in front of this home?
This is what some of these other homes need – a tree to distract from architecture that might be less-than-amazing.
Shutters or not? Exterior #8
“Maria, I was just wondering if shutters would work on my house! I need to repaint this summer and thought to add shutters BUT a shutter won’t fit on the window to the left of the side door where the exterior light fixture is. Is it ok to add shutters to only one side of a house?”
This house definitely would not look better with shutters. This is a perfect example of where landscaping is what we need. However, she brought up a point I want to make and that is this:
If a passerby can see both sides of your house from the street (like this above) and you decide to add shutters to the front of your house, you would also need to add them to the side you can see from the road as well.
This is another exterior detail you need to consider when deciding on shutters. How many sides of your home are viewable by the street?
Shutters or not? Exterior #9
I just want to tell you, I am so thankful I took your class. Not just because it helped with understanding colour but it also put a lot of renovation choices into perspective. The whole concept of renovation budget; I have an entirely new opinion on where I want to spend my money.Prior to your class, we were almost ready to commit to adding on a dormer/porch to the front of our house for $40K. We don’t gain much because we aren’t finishing out the extra square footage this time. We also wanted to dress the front of our house up for curb appeal, but that can be achieved with adding shutters, new exterior doors and a new garage door which is a far cry from $40K and that money didn’t include all those things I just mentioned, which if I don’t do those, then the new dormer/porch would look blah because it’s not decorated!I was so nervous to spend the money on the class, but immediately I have saved myself well over 10x the class in thinking differently about renovations as a whole. Thank you again!!
Super interesting post. My takeaway is, shutters are pointless unless you live in Europe and actually close them over your windows. I don’t want to criticize any particular house, but IMO, multiple window styles (single pane, multi-pane, rounded, square, arched, rectangular, double rectangular) in one house are an architect’s great failure and so typical of the McMansion era. PS. IMO, another reason shutters don’t work on your beautiful house, Maria, is the windows are not centered on the roofline (because your front door and portico are part of it) — shutters only emphasize that offset.
The historic houses in Charleston SC and Savannah GA have working shutters and I believe they were to protect from hurricanes. All this to say that I don’t think you need to live in Europe to have shutters if they work for your house or are there for functional reasons.
However, I do agree that shutters are usually awkward on houses with too many window styles.
The houses in Europe tend to be not as wildly different and WRONG as so many of them are in North America, there are some cases where adding shutters would make a difference even though the windows aren’t perfect for them, would a complete redesign be better? Sure but that is not reality for a lot of people. Thanks for your comment! Maria
Maria’s point about landscaping is so right and I would just like to add one comment. Notice the beautiful new house with the brick foundation where the front walk runs all the way from the driveway along the house and garage to the front door. That walkway was clearly placed too close to the house, not leaving enough depth for effective landscaping to break up the looooong structure. If a foundation planting is desired, a planting bed at least 6 – 9 feet deep is essential in order to layer in an effective mix of shrubs or small trees. Thanks for another informative and readable post, Maria!
That problem could be easily remedied by extending a wider planting bed in front of the walkway. It does look unfinished as the narrow bed behind can only hold plants in a single row.
Very interesting article! I agree with almost all of your recommendations.
I’m 50/50 on your house. The right side is very simple compared to the left. I think it the right side would look nice with shutters because then the windows would mirror the shapes created by the door and picture window on the left that both have sidelights.
I disagree with #2. I think that house looks better with the shutters even though there are a lot of them. It’s just lacking something in that stark color, and shutters on all the windows is a very traditional look for a house of that style. I definitely wouldn’t just put shutters on some. It’s all or nothing!
On #4, I would definitely get rid of the shutters on the arched window so it matches the larger arched window. I’d leave the rest because they balance each other.
Just an FYI – There are two exteriors labeled #6 so the numbering is off from there on.
LOVED these real-life examples! Definitely one of the best ways to learn! Thank you for such a great website. I’m grateful you are so generous with your blog. I can’t wait to build so I can get the whole house package lol!
Maria, I’d like to see your house with the triangle in front painted taupe. To me, it looks a bit like a face without eyebrows to have that peak above the windows in the same color as the rest of the body.
I think it’s so hard for people to imagine shrubs once mature so they think “stone!’ and “shutters!” I was on the HOA board in a previous neighborhood, and before one buyer even closed on the house, she put in a request to paint the shutters. We gave her the neighborhood palette, and she chose a dark gray for a tan house because she didn’t like the existing brown shutters. We approved it but no one thought it looked good. Just an example of the shutter obsession!
What an informative round up! On Exterior #4, I would love to see it photoshopped with no shutters. It’s very busy as is and I feel like taking something out of the visual field might help. If the shutters were removed, painting the door another color might be nice to shift some attention there. Also, a japanese maple with green foliage would be nice right in front of the tall window with the arch top.
Great post, Maria. We have old wooden shutters on our house (in the “correct” size) and keep replacing them as they fall apart. We find wood shutters mostly at flea markets and garage sales, so we always have a replacement on hand when one succumbs to age and weather. Thank you for another interesting, bordering on geek land, post.
Priscilla, how long do shutters last?
Wow, now that I see it without the shutters, the shutters will come down this weekend! Thanks so much Maria, very much appreciated.
In some cases the question should be about shutters, but more about ensuring that windows and doors are the same style or more effective paint colors. Also in cases where there is a blank spot, a vertical shrub or small tree would be more effective than throwing shutters on the house….
Great and interesting article. I don’t think you should forget the rear of a building just because it can’t be seen. My home, one of 4 townhouses is old but doesn’t look bad at the front but the back is just one big expanse of wall with windows stuck into holes in the wall and pretty ugly. I’d love it to look nicer but can’t imagine what could be done to improve it. Shutters aren’t an option as the windows are too wide. We have bushes and plantings along the building but they aren’t much help. Just bad design in the first place I think. I’m amazed at some of the houses around which have roof levels all over the place, arched windows and goodness knows what – and the back of the home is a flat ugly wall with some windows dotted here and there. “All fur coat and no knickers” is the expression that springs to mind!
I’m not saying the back of the house shouldn’t be pretty or that they shouldn’t have shutters, just that most people don’t add shutters there because it’s not a part of the curb appeal. I’d add shutters to the back of the house if I had money to burn, there are many other places in a house where your money is better spent. Just my opinion, doesn’t mean it’s right. Thanks for your comment. Maria
I complained for the past 29 years that we needed shutters on the back of our house that faces the woods. We replaced French doors leading out of our bedroom with double windows that shouldn’t have shutters anyway. He’s told me for years that people don’t look at the back of our house so why put them there? When I told my husband what you said about the back of the house not needing shutters, he said, “Maria Killam is now my favorite person. She gets me.”Haha!
I loved this blog post! Has to be one of my favorites!
Indeed, what a thought provoking post. It’s interesting, I was fining myself liking shutters on about 60% of the homes. I find I just didn’t like that blank space on the sides of the windows. My look, that my client’s hire me for, is a little more on the clean side, so I was amazed to see myself saying time and time again, nope, I like that home with shutters!
Very eye opening, thanks for the great post.
I am thinking I might just not like shutters! #4and #10. Looked like they fit, however, the rest did not feel right.
I think for many of these houses, in addition to landscaping, beefing up the mouldings around the windows and doors would add so much more visual interest than shutters. And adding muntins to the windows (if appropriate to the style of the house). Most houses built in the last 70 years are either lean on architectural details, or they have too much going on that doesn’t relate. For your home, I agree to not do shutters, and though not necessary with your gorgeous landscaping, I could envision framing out the entire openings of your porch all around to match the pretty post, and making the mouldings on the windows just a little more substantial.
You have done a magnificent job with your landscape and curb appeal, Maria! And building on what Kristi said, I agree that your house could look great by building out your porch a little more. Just guessing about the dimensions, it might be an additional 6×6 foot square supported by an additional pair of columns on the front matching the single one you already have. Place a peaked roof that follows the slope of the roof up to the center point of the new addition and then slopes back down at the same angle to the right side. That a might add a lot of architectural interest and feature the front entry a little more.
This is probably one of the most informative posts Maria has done and I find myself wishing I had done all white and green landscaping like hers. So fresh and beautiful!
I have a raised ranch with upper and lower level windows on the left side of my home that definitely don’t look right with shutters and keeping the shutters on the upper and lower level windows on the right side of the house would work but I think having shutters on one side of the house and not the other would look unbalanced and downright weird. All the other windows on my house are too large for shutters (I agree with Maria’s comment that if the shutters don’t cover the windows if you imagine them closed, then they won’t work) so all my shutters are coming off this week.
I would say that pictures of house plans show shutters on windows where there shouldn’t be and a lot of us have fallen victim to this, copying what we see without realizing the mistakes.
I’m also going to work on landscaping for curb appeal next year if all my freaking shrubs would stop dying with these North Country winters!
My conclusion is that America is shutter happy lol!
Good article but architecturally shutters are meant to look like they work…the pair should match the width of the window!
Great blog, Maria! I bought used your Exterior New Build guide & am patiently waiting for our home to be complete so I can see how this all paid off! 🙂 We will use exterior shutters sparsely on small, appropriate windows that would appear to close only.
What I would now LOVE to read is your take on timeless interior window treatments that allow lots of natural light in the day yet privacy at night, AND look like timeless curb appeal from the street view!
We will have craftsman framed white windows & I love the look of pale wood woven shades, but it seems difficult to find both filtered light for day that you can’t see right through at night. Classic white wood shutters are lovely, and good for the front-facing windows, but quite pricey to do throughout an entire new build all at once. Any timeless suggestions? 🙂
That was so cool! I loved the last house with the wide shutters, and the pergola over the garage. What a difference that makes. So many houses seem like a garage with a house attached, the garage being the biggest part of the design of the front. Love the red door on the one house too. What a difference!